Call Us for Free Consultation
 (714) 964-7851

How to Sell Unwanted Jewelry Without Getting Scammed

by | Apr 18, 2023

Most people have jewelry lying around that they no longer wear or use, yet understand its emotional value. You may be one of those people, and perhaps, you may have considered selling unwanted jewelry to make room for new jewelry but were worried about getting scammed. At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., the preferred jewelry store in Fountain Valley, we understand your treasures’ sentimental and financial value. Selling your jewelry should not be a stressful experience, and we are here to help you make it a seamless and enjoyable process. Let us guide you with all the information you need to confidently sell your jewelry and turn it into a sidewalk stroll instead of a suspended tightrope walk.


Quick Review of Key Points

Additionally, you may want to consider working with a professional appraiser like Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., who can help you determine an accurate value for the jewelry and ensure you receive a fair price.


Where to Sell Unwanted Jewelry

When selling unwanted jewelry, knowing where you can sell it and the best places to get the most value for your items is important. Generally, the best places to sell unwanted jewelry are through jewelers, local pawn shops, or online marketplaces.

Selling on eBay is a popular option – buyers worldwide can come together in one auction-style environment. You can reach a virtually unlimited audience by listing jewelry on eBay and potentially maximize profits. However, there is a downside to selling jewelry on eBay; each item must be shipped, and you may face payment complications or be exposed to a higher risk of fraud.

Local pawnshops are often overlooked as an option for selling unwanted jewelry. However, pawnshops offer better returns than other retail stores and typically deal with jewelry more regularly. The downside of selling at pawnshops is that they may take what they like and reject what they don’t want. Additionally, because this type of store is usually owner-operated, terms can vary widely among different shops, so it’s important to research before making a deal.

Mimi’s Jewelry Inc. also offers us the option to trade in or sell your unwanted jewelry directly. As a local jeweler, we understand the value of every piece and ensure you receive a fair market price for your items. Plus, we offer the added advantage of paying immediately in cash or check, thereby reducing any risk of fraud. However, it’s important to note that not all local jewelers accept certain materials or styles of jewelry, and it’s important to shop around for the best deal before settling in one place. At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we provide a transparent and trustworthy process that guarantees customer satisfaction.

No matter which routes you choose for selling unwanted jewelry, researching beforehand is essential to ensure optimal results. Now that we have discussed the various sale channels available for disposing of unwanted jewelry let’s discuss another popular sale channel – eBay Marketplace.


Essential Points

When trying to sell unwanted jewelry, eBay is a good option due to its vast global audience, but it is not without risks, such as shipping complications or potential fraud. Jewelers and pawnshops generally provide better returns than other stores and might give immediate cash/check payments. Researching all three options is essential before settling on one to ensure optimal results.


eBay Marketplace

The eBay Marketplace is a popular platform for selling unwanted jewelry. Many buyers trust the website for its well-known brand, vast selection, and user-friendly features. On the positive side, eBay has a reputation for offering good customer service and ensuring buyers and sellers feel like their interests are being considered.

However, some potential cons to selling on eBay should be considered before committing. Depending on the type of jewelry you’re selling and the competition within that particular market, you might not make as much money as you would when selling through other venues. For example, vintage jewelry may be more valuable in a specialty shop compared to an online marketplace like eBay. Additionally, some fees associated with using eBay might leave less money in your pocket after the sale.

If you have carefully weighed these pros and cons and have decided that eBay is the right choice for selling your unwanted jewelry, it’s important to remember that there are still certain risks involved with any purchase made online. Even though this reputable marketplace generally provides safe buying and selling experiences, it’s still possible to be scammed or robbed while attempting a sale on eBay. Therefore, research every potential buyer thoroughly before agreeing to a transaction.

Now that we’ve discussed how to approach selling unwanted jewelry on the eBay Marketplace let’s turn our attention to another common option: pawn shops.


Pawn Shops

Perhaps the most common avenue for selling unwanted jewelry is visiting a pawn shop. Pawnbrokers have long been involved in the buying and selling of used jewelry. However, depending on the state, pawn shops may be heavily regulated, making the transaction less favorable for those looking to get a good return on their investment. On the one hand, the regulation can serve as protection for consumers by minimizing illegal and shady businesses taking advantage of the desperation of those looking to cash in. On the other hand, some agreements involve high-interest rates and terms that may not be favorable to everyone.

Overall, when it comes to pawn shops and selling unwanted jewelry, it’s important to do your due diligence before entering into such an agreement. Determining if the shop is reputable and willing to negotiate a fair amount for your items is essential. Additionally, it’s wise to look into the state’s regulations regarding the pawnbroker industry, so you know what type of deal you are agreeing to with a particular shop before signing anything.

Finally, be prepared with relevant information about your items. Gather credentials from any appraisals, receipts, or certificates of authenticity that accompany them so you can present them accurately and confidently to get the best price for your items.

Now that you know more about pawn shops as an option for selling unwanted jewelry, let’s move on to exploring how to find a trustworthy buyer in our next section.


Finding a Trustworthy Buyer

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we understand that selling unwanted jewelry can be daunting, and finding a trustworthy buyer is crucial. We prioritize transparency, honesty, and customer satisfaction in every transaction. Our team of experts will carefully evaluate your jewelry and provide you with a fair price that reflects its true value. We handle every piece with care and respect, ensuring your jewelry is in good hands throughout the selling process. As a reputable and established jewelry store, we are committed to providing a legitimate and trustworthy service to all our customers.

The advantage of using an independent buyer or antique shop is that they may give you more money than you would receive from online sites, but they may also be less reliable, and it can be challenging to verify the quality or authenticity of the material being purchased. Meeting face-to-face with the potential buyers, asking them about their credentials, and viewing any written documents can help alleviate worries about ensuring all transactions are conducted safely and securely.

For those who want to sell unwanted jewelry without risking being scammed, researching reputable resources like Mimi’s Jewelry Inc. can help ensure a successful sale while getting a fair price for their goods. The following section will discuss different avenues when researching credible buyers for sellers of unwanted jewelry.


Researching Reputable Resources

When it comes to selling unwanted jewelry, research is vital. As a seller, you want to ensure you’re getting the highest price possible without getting ripped off. When researching resources, there are two schools of thought: working with an individual buyer or a larger institution.


Individual Buyers

Individual buyers offer more convenience and the potential for a better deal; however, it can be difficult to find someone you know and trust who is willing to buy jewelry (roughly estimated at up to 50% of its appraised value). Individual buyers usually prefer specific stones and metals, so they might not be interested in your unwanted jewelry.



Another option is working with an institution such as a reputed jeweler like Mimi’s Jewelry Inc. At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we offer premium selling services that provide access to a range of resources that an individual buyer may not have. Our services include resizing and polishing your jewelry before the sale, ensuring your pieces are presented in their best possible light. At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we are committed to providing you with a premium selling experience that maximizes your jewelry’s value and gives you the best possible outcome.

Ultimately, as a seller, you must carefully weigh both sides when researching reputable resources for selling your jewelry. Understanding both options can help you get the best bang for your buck financially and time-wise.

Now that we have discussed researching reputable resources for selling unwanted jewelry, the next step is ensuring you’re not scammed.


Making Sure You’re Not Scammed

Selling unwanted jewelry is a great way to make money, but it’s important to be aware of the risks and know how to protect yourself from getting scammed. You can take several steps to ensure your transaction is legitimate before, during, and after the sale of your jewelry.

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we understand the importance of ensuring our customers have complete confidence in our services. We take pride in our reputation as a trustworthy and reputable buyer of unwanted jewelry. We encourage you to research online reviews and customer feedback to learn more about our services, and we are happy to provide references from customers who have sold jewelry with us in the past. At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., you can rest assured that you are dealing with a reputable and trustworthy buyer of unwanted jewelry.

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we believe in transparency and fairness in every transaction we make. We encourage our customers to carefully read all paperwork before agreeing to a deal, and we ensure all promises made are included in the contract or agreement.

To get an accurate estimate of the worth of your jewelry, we recommend obtaining an appraisal from an experienced appraiser like Mimi’s Jewelry, affiliated with a national organization like the American Society of Appraisers (ASA). The written appraisal will include your jewelry’s size, cut, carat weight, metal type, condition, replacement value, and estimated resale value. This information can help you maximize your sale price while avoiding potential scams.

When it comes time for payment, we offer payment in the form of a check or cash. We also ensure our digital payment methods are secure before offering them as an option. At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we strive to make every transaction as secure and transparent as possible, providing our customers with the peace of mind they deserve.

By taking these simple precautionary measures, you can help protect yourself from being scammed when selling unwanted jewelry. Now that we’ve discussed how to avoid getting scammed when selling unwanted jewelry let’s move on to discuss appraisal and payments in detail in the following section.


Appraisal and Payment

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we understand that knowing the true value of your jewelry is crucial before accepting any payment. Our jewelry store offers free, no-obligation evaluations of your unwanted jewelry to help you accurately estimate its value. Our experienced team of appraisers will carefully evaluate your piece and provide you with a fair market value price.

For those who may not have access to a professional appraisal, more affordable options are available. Online guides can provide a general idea of the market value of your piece, and experienced family members or friends who are knowledgeable in jewelry can also help you determine its worth. However, we recommend obtaining a professional appraisal for the most accurate estimate of your jewelry’s value.

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we prioritize transparency and customer satisfaction in every transaction we make. We believe that knowing the value of your jewelry is essential to a fair and satisfactory sale, and we are committed to providing our customers with the information they need to make informed decisions about their jewelry.

It is crucial to ensure you receive adequate payments for your jewelry. If you are dealing with a private buyer or pawnbroker, negotiating is advisable to receive the best price possible. Cash payments are preferred. However, some establishments may only offer items such as store credit. Try to weigh out the pros and cons of each option before making a decision you will regret later on.

When accepting payments from private buyers, be aware that scams run rampant within this market sector. It is good practice to meet a prospective buyer in public and never provide personal information or send money through a third-party service like Western Union unless absolutely necessary. While cash transactions are viewed as ideal in this circumstance, accept cheques only when you fully trust the buyer. If needed, speak with both parties’ banks directly to confirm security and backing before agreeing to any purchases or drawings from accounts.

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we understand that getting paid quickly and securely is a top priority when selling unwanted jewelry. That’s why we offer multiple payment options to our customers, including cash, check, and wire transfers. Our payment process is straightforward, and we ensure our customers receive their payment promptly and securely.

We also prioritize the security and safety of our customer’s transactions. We take all necessary precautions to prevent fraud and scams, including thorough evaluation and authentication of each piece of jewelry we purchase. Our expert team has years of industry experience and is committed to providing our customers with a safe and secure transaction process.

Now that we’ve discussed how the appraisal and payment process works when selling unwanted jewelry let’s move on to other alternative options in our next section…


Alternative Options

When it comes to selling unwanted jewelry without getting scammed, a few alternative options are available. Consumers can choose to part with their jewelry by taking the item to a reputable pawn shop or opting for a luxury buy-back program.

Reputable pawn shops are often able to offer higher rates as they are in the business of reselling gold items. However, consumers should remember that pawnshops will only be able to return a fraction of what they paid initially and that this option might come with the risk of being undervalued.

Choosing a luxury buy-back program may provide a more secure option, but again, there will almost always be a trade-off between security and value. This means consumers likely won’t return their full retail price for the piece. It is also important to consider other fees and associated costs when choosing between different buy-back programs, as some may offer better deals than others.

It all comes down to weighing up potential losses versus time saved to decide which option works best for them. Let’s move on to the next section and look at how consumers can safely sell unwanted jewelry without being scammed.


Selling Unwanted Jewelry Without Being Scammed

Selling unwanted jewelry can be a great way to make some extra money. However, it’s essential to know how to do it without being scammed. Fortunately, you can take some simple steps to ensure you get a fair market value for your jewelry without getting ripped off.

Firstly, research current market prices of the type and quality of the jewelry you are trying to sell. This information will help you decide on a reasonable price range. You can also use this information to determine if an offer is too good. An accurate understanding of your jewelry’s worth will give you an upper hand when negotiating with buyers and prevent possible scams.

It’s best to avoid selling jewelry online, as this leaves you vulnerable to scams and manipulation by buyers. Physical meetings with potential buyers allow you to inspect the items and discuss transaction details face-to-face properly. It also allows them to fully appreciate the beauty of the pieces before purchasing. Professional appraisers and jewelers, such as Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., may also be able to help with assessments and paperwork, such as appraisals if needed.

Additionally, if you are dealing with someone from another country, be aware that any funds received may get caught up in international banking delays or, even worse – not arrive at all or have unexpected costs added for the transfer to go through successfully. It’s best practice to ask all buyers upfront whether to pay in cash or use any other payment method (such as PayPal). Furthermore, ensure payment is completed in full before anything is shipped out, as international shipping laws can often make it difficult for additional payments after dispatching has been made.

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we prioritize customer satisfaction and security in every transaction. Our team of experts will guide you through the selling process, ensuring you are comfortable with every step. We understand the importance of trust in the jewelry industry, and we strive to establish a relationship of trust with every customer. With over 20 years of experience in the industry, we have built a reputation as a trustworthy and legitimate jewelry store. We encourage our customers to ask any questions they may have and to voice any concerns. Our goal is to provide seamless and secure transactions for all our customers.

Mimi’s Jewelry Inc. is a family-owned custom jewelry store that has served Fountain Valley and Orange County residents for three generations. Fox News has recognized the store as the #1 jeweler in Orange County for three consecutive years (2009, 2010, and 2011) and has been the preferred jeweler in Fountain Valley for the past 20 years. With a team of certified Gemologists and Master Jewelers, Mimi’s Jewelry, Inc. provides the highest payouts for unwanted jewelry, watches, and diamonds to ensure their customers receive the best value for their items.


Frequently Asked Questions and Explanations 


Are there any reliable websites that I can use to sell my jewelry?

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we understand that selling jewelry online can be convenient, especially for those who prefer to avoid the traditional selling process. We recommend using reputable websites such as eBay, Etsy, Reverb, 1stDibs, Worthy, and TrueFacet to sell your jewelry online. These websites offer various levels of protection for sellers and secure forms of payment for buyers. Additionally, they provide specialized services like an appraisal, secure shipping connections with insured carriers, and more, making the selling process more efficient and secure. However, the best option to sell unwanted jewelry is at a reputable jewelry store such as Mimi’s Jewelry, the preferred jeweler in Fountain Valley. Contact us today to learn how we can help you sell unwanted jewelry.


What steps must I follow to ensure I am not scammed when selling my jewelry?

Follows these tips from Mimi’s Jewelry Inc. when selling unwanted jewelry. The most important thing to do to ensure you are not scammed is to take steps to protect yourself. Here are the main steps you should take:

  1. Make sure you have an accurate appraisal of your jewelry before you commit to any sale. Knowing the true value of your jewelry is essential for properly negotiating a deal and ensuring you aren’t duped into receiving substantially less than what it’s actually worth.
  2. Research potential buyers or sellers thoroughly. Always seek out legitimate businesses or organizations if possible, as these tend to be more reputable and less likely to scam you. Furthermore, check reviews of buyers/sellers before agreeing to work with them, so you can get an idea of their trustworthiness.
  3. Get everything in writing. Don’t just accept verbal agreements when selling jewelry; make sure all the details of your agreement are written and signed by both parties, including any financial terms and other conditions such as delivery dates or returns policies. This will help protect both parties and make it easier to enforce the terms of the agreement if necessary.
  4. Insure your shipment when sending items through the mail. Insurance can help safeguard against theft or loss during shipping and provide protection against fraud if necessary. It’s usually a good idea to at least get basic insurance coverage when sending jewelry through the mail to protect you in case anything goes wrong en route.
  5. Do your due diligence when engaging in online transactions or meeting people in person for the first time. Make sure that payment methods are secure and legitimate; double-check contact information such as phone numbers, addresses, and emails; use caution when meeting people face-to-face; and always remain aware of your surroundings by keeping personal items close and staying alert while making transactions.

By following these simple steps, you can ensure you’re getting a fair deal when selling unwanted jewelry without falling victim to any scams! At Mimi’s Jewelry, we guarantee to provide you with a seamless end-to-end jewelry buying and selling experience. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help you sell your unwanted jewelry.


What items should I watch out for when selling my jewelry?

When selling your jewelry, Mimi’s Jewelry points out a few key elements that could be used to scam you.

First, ensure you are not undervalued due to something called “filler metal.” Filler metal is often added to precious metals to lower the overall value, so it’s important to have your piece evaluated by an expert before selling.

Second, if you’re selling precious gems, be sure to get them appraised as well. Many unscrupulous consignors may try and pass off imitation stones as the real thing to make more money, so getting the gems inspected by a certified gemologist is essential.

Third, beware of unethical brokers who try and increase their profits by charging exorbitant commission rates or fees. Do your research beforehand and ask potential buyers if they charge extra fees for their services so you don’t get taken advantage of.

Finally, avoid agreeing to any hidden terms or conditions when selling your jewelry. A reputable buyer like Mimi’s Jewelry will have no problem disclosing all possible fees upfront so you can make an informed decision about the sale. If there’s anything shady mentioned during negotiations, it’s probably best to walk away and find another buyer instead.


How long does it take to sell unwanted jewelry?

For Mimi’s Jewelry Inc. – The amount of time it takes to sell unwanted jewelry depends on a variety of factors unique to each piece, such as the type of jewelry, its condition, market demand, and the method used to sell it.

In the case of jewelry that is in excellent condition and has a popular style or is crafted from valuable materials, it can typically be sold relatively quickly. However, it may take longer to find a buyer for jewelry that is in poor condition or outdated style.

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., our experienced professionals can help evaluate and determine the best method to sell your jewelry quickly and efficiently. Contact us today to learn more about how we can help you sell your unwanted jewelry.

What are the best places to sell unwanted jewelry?
The ideal places to sell unwanted jewelry will depend on several factors, including the type of jewelry, its condition, and the amount of money you want to receive.

If you’re hoping to obtain the highest possible payout for your jewelry, you should consider selling it to Mimi’s Jewelry Inc. or a reputable local jewelry store. Many of these establishments have experienced appraisers who can assess your jewelry’s value and offer you a competitive price for high-quality pieces. We take pride in offering fair prices for all jewelry we purchase and have built a reputation as a trusted buyer of unwanted jewelry.

Alternatively, if you’re looking for a quick sale or need cash immediately, you may consider selling your jewelry to a pawn shop. However, keep in mind that pawn shops typically offer lower prices than jewelry stores or buyers.

At Mimi’s Jewelry Inc., we offer a wide range of services to help you sell your unwanted jewelry, including direct buying, consignment, and auctions. Contact us today to schedule a consultation with one of our experienced jewelry appraisers to discuss the best options for selling your jewelry.





Connect with one of our jewelry experts to experience the Mimi's Jewelry difference! Feel free to stop by our shop or schedule an appointment online.